05-004 · EVIDENCE A · SOURCE-SENSITIVE

Recalculate your mobile and broadband plans annually: downgrade unused services, and file a complaint if the carrier refuses to comply

每年重算一次手机和宽带套餐,用不上的降档,运营商不给转就投诉

Source cost

No expense at all. It takes just a few minutes to review your bill. The real challenge is resisting the pressure from customer service reps who try to dissuade you from downgrading.

Source return

Older plans you’re currently on often cost dozens of yuan more per month than newer plans now on sale. Those extra monthly fees add up to hundreds of yuan wasted each year. By regulation, carriers have no valid reason to reject your request to switch plans, delay processing it, or impose special pricing tiers solely for customers making such changes. If they refuse without justification, you can file a formal complaint.

Evidence grade

A

THE LOW-ROI DETOURSatire, not advice

Move “Recalculate your mobile and broadband plans annually: downgrade unused services, and file a complaint if the carrier refuses to comply” to Future Me's calendar

The excuse

There is no immediate alarm, so the sensible choice can wait for a less busy week.

What feels good now

Today I keep a few minutes, a bit of persistence and avoid interrupting my default routine.

What the source says

The source summarizes the return this way: “Older plans you’re currently on often cost dozens of yuan more per month than newer plans now on sale. Those extra monthly fees add up to hundreds of yuan wasted each year. By regulation, carriers have no valid reason to reject your request to switch plans, delay processing it, or impose special pricing tiers solely for customers making such changes. If they refuse without justification, you can file a formal complaint.” Evidence grade A. The original states the population, caveats, and sources; this is not a personal forecast.

THE ENGLISH EDITION

Original recommendation and evidence

Source commit a994b6a0c905

4. Recalculate your mobile and broadband plans annually: downgrade unused services, and file a complaint if the carrier refuses to comply

Cost: No expense at all. It takes just a few minutes to review your bill. The real challenge is resisting the pressure from customer service reps who try to dissuade you from downgrading.

In plain terms: Older plans you’re currently on often cost dozens of yuan more per month than newer plans now on sale. Those extra monthly fees add up to hundreds of yuan wasted each year. By regulation, carriers have no valid reason to reject your request to switch plans, delay processing it, or impose special pricing tiers solely for customers making such changes. If they refuse without justification, you can file a formal complaint.

Benefit: Ministry of Industry and Information Technology rules explicitly state that carriers must not “refuse, obstruct, or delay providing number portability services to users without valid reasons”, nor may they “use blocking or restrictive technical measures to compromise the communication service quality of such users”. They are also prohibited from “creating dedicated pricing or marketing plans for customers exercising their right to port their numbers”. Older plans typically cost dozens of yuan more per month than current offerings, so sticking with them results in hundreds of yuan wasted annually.

Evidence grade: A

Sources: Ministry of Industry and Information Technology of China (2019). Provisions on the Management of Number Portability Services (Ministry of Industry and Information Technology of China Information Management [2019] No. 242). <http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2019-11/13/content_5451483.htm>

Notes: First, use your carrier’s official app to check your actual monthly data and call usage over the past six months, then choose a plan matching those figures. If a customer service rep claims “you must visit a physical store to downgrade” or “contract terms prevent any changes”, ask for written proof of those claims. If none is provided, file a complaint via the 12300 hotline.

Read the complete Chinese source and notes

4. 每年重算一次手机和宽带套餐,用不上的降档,运营商不给转就投诉

成本: 不花钱。查一次账单,十几分钟。难的是要顶住客服不给你降档。

说人话: 你用的老套餐,往往比现在新卖的贵几十块钱。一个月几十,一年就是几百块白扔。按规定,运营商没有正当理由,不能拒绝你转网,也不能拖着不给你办,更不能专门给转网的人单独设一套资费。它卡着不放,你就投诉。

收益: 工信部的规章写明,运营商不得「无正当理由拒绝、阻止、拖延向用户提供携号转网服务」。也不得「采取拦截、限制等技术手段影响携号转网用户的通信服务质量」。还不得「为携号转网用户设置专项资费方案和营销方案」。老套餐往往比现在在售的套餐贵几十元。一直不换,就是每年白扔几百元

证据等级: A

来源: 工业和信息化部 (2019). 携号转网服务管理规定(工信部信管〔2019〕242 号). <http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2019-11/13/content_5451483.htm>

备注: 先在营业厅 App 里查你近半年实际用了多少流量和通话,再按这个用量去选套餐。客服要是说「降档得到营业厅办」「合约期内不能改」,你就要求他给出书面依据。他给不出,就打 12300 投诉

Author's scope notes: 先在营业厅 App 里查你近半年实际用了多少流量和通话,再按这个用量去选套餐。客服要是说「降档得到营业厅办」「合约期内不能改」,你就要求他给出书面依据。他给不出,就打 12300 投诉

YOUR PRIVATE LIST

Choose what to do with this idea

Original content by eternity4719 under CC BY 4.0. English translation is credited in the source notes. HowToLiveWorse adds a clearly labeled satirical response.

Full source and adaptation notes