14-009 · EVIDENCE A · SOURCE-SENSITIVE
You’re not required to use facial recognition: if other options exist, they must offer you alternatives if you refuse
刷脸不是必须答应的:有别的办法就不能只让你刷脸,你不同意得给你其他方式
No cost involved. When asked to use facial recognition, simply ask, “Are there any other verification methods available?” If they claim none exist, demand they provide alternatives. The challenge lies in actually voicing this question on the spot.
As long as any other method can achieve the same result, a service provider cannot force you to use facial recognition. If you decline facial recognition, they must offer alternatives such as a card swipe, password entry, or ID verification. They also cannot threaten that “the service won’t be provided” if you refuse. Installing facial recognition devices in hotel rooms, public showers, changing rooms, or restrooms is strictly prohibited.
A
Move “You’re not required to use facial recognition: if other options exist, they must offer you alternatives if you refuse” to Future Me's calendar
The excuse
The routine already works until the day the source says it may not.
What feels good now
Today I keep a few minutes, a bit of persistence and avoid interrupting my default routine.
What the source says
The source summarizes the return this way: “As long as any other method can achieve the same result, a service provider cannot force you to use facial recognition. If you decline facial recognition, they must offer alternatives such as a card swipe, password entry, or ID verification. They also cannot threaten that “the service won’t be provided” if you refuse. Installing facial recognition devices in hotel rooms, public showers, changing rooms, or restrooms is strictly prohibited.” Evidence grade A. The original states the population, caveats, and sources; this is not a personal forecast.
Use the original facts and limits. For an urgent medical, safety, financial, or legal issue, contact a qualified local professional or service.
THE ENGLISH EDITION
Original recommendation and evidence
9. You’re not required to use facial recognition: if other options exist, they must offer you alternatives if you refuse
Cost: No cost involved. When asked to use facial recognition, simply ask, “Are there any other verification methods available?” If they claim none exist, demand they provide alternatives. The challenge lies in actually voicing this question on the spot.
In plain terms: As long as any other method can achieve the same result, a service provider cannot force you to use facial recognition. If you decline facial recognition, they must offer alternatives such as a card swipe, password entry, or ID verification. They also cannot threaten that “the service won’t be provided” if you refuse. Installing facial recognition devices in hotel rooms, public showers, changing rooms, or restrooms is strictly prohibited.
Benefit: The Administrative Measures for the Safe Use of Facial Recognition Technology clearly state: “Where other non-facial recognition technologies can achieve the same purpose or meet equivalent operational requirements, facial recognition must not be used as the sole verification method. If an individual declines facial recognition for identity verification, other reasonable and convenient alternatives must be provided.” The measures further stipulate: “No organization or individual may mislead, deceive, or coerce individuals into accepting facial recognition for identity verification under the pretext of service delivery or improved quality.” Consent to use facial recognition must be “freely, explicitly, and separately given after full disclosure” — meaning you must be asked specifically about this and must agree independently. You retain the right to withdraw consent, and service providers must offer an easy way to do so. For minors under 14, parental or guardian consent is mandatory. In public spaces, facial recognition devices may only be installed if “necessary for public safety” and must display prominent warning signs. Their use inside private areas such as hotel rooms, showers, changing rooms, or restrooms is forbidden. Facial data must be stored locally on devices and must not be transmitted over the internet, except where permitted by law or with explicit consent (effective nationwide as of June 1, 2025).
Evidence grade: A
Notes: Common scenarios include residential building access systems, rental platforms, gyms, and hotels requesting facial data. When they claim “the system only supports facial recognition,” quote the exact wording from the regulations: “Where other non-facial recognition technologies can achieve the same purpose or meet equivalent operational requirements, facial recognition must not be used as the sole verification method.” Then demand alternative verification methods such as card swipes, passwords, or ID checks. If they still refuse, report them to local internet regulatory authorities. Certain financial and government services may have separate rules — follow those instead. Unlike passwords, facial data cannot be changed after a breach, so it demands greater caution. Organizations storing facial data on behalf of 100,000+ individuals must register with provincial or higher-level internet regulators within 30 days; this registration status can help you assess their legitimacy. Your rights to access, correct, or delete your personal data are covered in item 8.
Sources: Cyberspace Administration of China, Ministry of Public Security of China (2025). Measures for the Security Management of Facial Recognition Technology Applications (Order No. 19, Article 10, Article 12, Article 13, effective from June 1, 2025). <https://www.cac.gov.cn/2025-03/21/c_1744174262156096.htm>
Read the complete Chinese source and notes
9. 刷脸不是必须答应的:有别的办法就不能只让你刷脸,你不同意得给你其他方式
成本: 不花钱。被要求刷脸时,问一句「有没有别的验证方式」。对方说没有,就要求它提供一个。难的是要当面开口问。
说人话: 只要还有别的办法能办成同一件事,对方就不能只让你刷脸。你不同意刷脸,它得给你刷卡、密码或者身份证这类别的办法,也不许拿「那就办不了业务」来逼你。宾馆客房、公共浴室、更衣室、卫生间这些地方,谁都不许装人脸识别设备。
收益: 人脸识别技术应用安全管理办法写明:「实现相同目的或者达到同等业务要求,存在其他非人脸识别技术方式的,不得将人脸识别技术作为唯一验证方式。个人不同意通过人脸信息进行身份验证的,应当提供其他合理、便捷的方式。」办法还写明:「任何组织和个人不得以办理业务、提升服务质量等为由,误导、欺诈、胁迫个人接受人脸识别技术验证个人身份。」要是按你同意来处理人脸信息,得取得「在充分知情的前提下自愿、明确作出的单独同意」:单独就这一件事问你,你单独点头才算。你有权撤回同意,处理者要提供便捷的撤回方式。处理不满十四周岁未成年人的人脸信息,应当取得父母或者其他监护人的同意。公共场所安装人脸识别设备,「应当为维护公共安全所必需」,并设置显著提示标识。宾馆客房、公共浴室、公共更衣室、公共卫生间等公共场所中的私密空间内部,任何组织和个人不得安装。人脸信息应当存储于人脸识别设备内,不得通过互联网对外传输。两种情况例外:法律、行政法规另有规定,或者取得了单独同意(全国,2025 年 6 月 1 日起施行)
证据等级: A
来源: 国家互联网信息办公室、公安部 (2025). 人脸识别技术应用安全管理办法(第 19 号令,第十条、十二条、十三条,2025 年 6 月 1 日起施行). <https://www.cac.gov.cn/2025-03/21/c_1744174262156096.htm>
备注: 最常遇到的是小区门禁、租房平台、健身房、酒店要你录人脸。对方说「系统只支持刷脸」的时候,把办法的原话念给他听。原话是:「实现相同目的或者达到同等业务要求,存在其他非人脸识别技术方式的,不得将人脸识别技术作为唯一验证方式」。然后要求它提供刷卡、密码或者身份证这类别的方式。还是不给的,向当地网信部门反映。国家对刷脸验证身份另有规定的,比如一部分金融和政务场景,按那些规定办。人脸和密码最大的区别是泄露之后改不掉,所以它值得比密码更谨慎。存了 10 万人以上人脸信息的单位,要在 30 个工作日内向省级以上网信部门备案,这也是判断对方正不正规的一个问法。查阅、更正、删除自己个人信息的权利见第 8 条。别人借你的脸去办他自己的贷款,是另一回事,见第 8 节第 45 条(帮忙刷个脸)。
YOUR PRIVATE LIST