24-006 · EVIDENCE A · SOURCE-SENSITIVE

If you have doubts about treatment, request to seal the medical records on the spot; both parties must be present, a list must be drawn up, and each side gets a copy.

对诊疗有疑问就当场要求封存病历,双方在场、开清单、各执一份

Source cost

No cost at all. Simply ask the hospital to seal the records; both you and the medical staff must be present to complete the paperwork. The real challenge is mustering the courage to say this out loud in front of the doctors.

Source return

If you’re unsure about any aspect of your treatment, you have the right to request that your medical records be sealed. Both you and the medical staff must be present for this process, which involves creating a detailed list, signing and stamping it, and each side receiving a copy. If the records aren’t fully completed yet, only the finished portions should be sealed first; the rest can be sealed later. Should you suspect that an intravenous infusion, blood transfusion, injection, or medication caused a problem, the actual fluid bag, medicine vial, and infusion set must also be sealed together with the records.

Evidence grade

A

THE LOW-ROI DETOURSatire, not advice

Move “If you have doubts about treatment, request to seal the medical records on the spot; both parties must be present, a list must be drawn up, and each side gets a copy.” to Future Me's calendar

The excuse

There is no immediate alarm, so the sensible choice can wait for a less busy week.

What feels good now

Today I keep a few minutes, a bit of persistence and avoid interrupting my default routine.

What the source says

The source summarizes the return this way: “If you’re unsure about any aspect of your treatment, you have the right to request that your medical records be sealed. Both you and the medical staff must be present for this process, which involves creating a detailed list, signing and stamping it, and each side receiving a copy. If the records aren’t fully completed yet, only the finished portions should be sealed first; the rest can be sealed later. Should you suspect that an intravenous infusion, blood transfusion, injection, or medication caused a problem, the actual fluid bag, medicine vial, and infusion set must also be sealed together with the records.” Evidence grade A. The original states the population, caveats, and sources; this is not a personal forecast.

THE ENGLISH EDITION

Original recommendation and evidence

Source commit a994b6a0c905

6. If you have doubts about treatment, request to seal the medical records on the spot; both parties must be present, a list must be drawn up, and each side gets a copy.

Cost: No cost at all. Simply ask the hospital to seal the records; both you and the medical staff must be present to complete the paperwork. The real challenge is mustering the courage to say this out loud in front of the doctors.

In plain terms: If you’re unsure about any aspect of your treatment, you have the right to request that your medical records be sealed. Both you and the medical staff must be present for this process, which involves creating a detailed list, signing and stamping it, and each side receiving a copy. If the records aren’t fully completed yet, only the finished portions should be sealed first; the rest can be sealed later. Should you suspect that an intravenous infusion, blood transfusion, injection, or medication caused a problem, the actual fluid bag, medicine vial, and infusion set must also be sealed together with the records.

Benefit: Regulations clearly state that “whenever a medical dispute arises and it is necessary to seal or unseal medical records, this must be done while both the patient and medical staff are present.” The sealed documents may be either originals or copies, which the hospital then stores. If the records are still being written, only the completed sections should be sealed first; the remainder can be sealed later. The hospital must produce a sealing list, signed or stamped by both parties, with each side keeping a copy. In cases where an adverse effect is suspected to stem from an IV, blood transfusion, injection, or medication, both parties must jointly seal and later unseal any related physical items. If testing is required, both parties must jointly appoint a qualified laboratory; should they fail to agree, the local health authority at the county level where the hospital is located will make the appointment. Should a transfusion-related problem be suspected and blood samples need sealing, the hospital must notify the blood bank to send representatives to the scene. Additionally, there is a strict rule: “No organization or individual may alter, forge, conceal, destroy, or seize medical records.” Once a dispute is resolved or three years pass without any further claims, the hospital may unseal the documents on its own initiative (nationwide, effective 1 October 2018).

Evidence grade: A

Sources: State Council of China (2018). Regulations on the Prevention and Handling of Medical Disputes (State Council of China Order No. 701, Articles 15, 24, and 25). <https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2018-08/31/content_5318057.htm>

Notes: Sealing records and making copies are two distinct actions. Copying records is something you should do proactively, as explained in item 7 (always keep your own copies of medical records and imaging). Sealing, on the other hand, serves to preserve evidence at the moment a dispute arises, preventing any later alterations or additions. If you suspect that an IV, blood transfusion, injection, or medication caused a problem, you must seal not only the records but also the fluid bag, medicine vial, and infusion set; otherwise they might be removed or discarded. Hospitals are required to prominently display information about dispute resolution procedures, contact details, and to maintain a dedicated complaints department. In case of any issue, approach that department rather than confronting the attending physician directly.

Read the complete Chinese source and notes

6. 对诊疗有疑问就当场要求封存病历,双方在场、开清单、各执一份

成本: 不花钱。向医院提出封存要求,等医患双方到场把手续做完。难在当着医生的面把这句话说出口。

说人话: 对治疗有疑问,可以要求把病历封存起来。封存要医患双方都在场,开清单、签字盖章、各拿一份。病历还没写完的,先封已经写完的那部分。怀疑是输液、输血、打针、用药出的问题,那袋液体、那支药和输液器要一起封存。

收益: 条例规定「发生医疗纠纷需要封存、启封病历资料的,应当在医患双方在场的情况下进行」。封存的可以是原件,也可以是复制件,由医疗机构保管。病历尚未完成需要封存的,对已完成部分先行封存,后续完成后再封存。医疗机构应当对封存的病历开列封存清单,由医患双方签字或者盖章,各执一份。疑似输液、输血、注射、用药等引起不良后果的,医患双方应当共同对现场实物进行封存、启封。需要检验的,应当由双方共同委托有检验资格的机构。双方无法共同委托的,由医疗机构所在地县级人民政府卫生主管部门指定。疑似输血引起不良后果、需要封存血液的,医疗机构应当通知血站派员到场。另有一条硬约束:「任何单位和个人不得篡改、伪造、隐匿、毁灭或者抢夺病历资料。」封存后纠纷已解决,或者满 3 年未再提出解决要求的,医疗机构可以自行启封(全国,2018 年 10 月 1 日起施行)

证据等级: A

来源: 国务院 (2018). 医疗纠纷预防和处理条例(国务院令第 701 号,第十五、二十四、二十五条). <https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2018-08/31/content_5318057.htm>

备注: 封存和复印是两件事。复印是平时就该做的,见第 5 条(病历和影像自己存一份)。封存是纠纷发生时把证据固定住,防的是事后补写和修改。怀疑是输液、输血、用药出的问题,除了病历,还要一起封存那袋液体、那支药和输液器,别让人收走扔掉。医疗机构应当在显著位置公布医疗纠纷的解决途径、程序和联系方式,并设置统一的投诉管理部门。有事先找那个部门,不要找当班医生理论。

Author's scope notes: 封存和复印是两件事。复印是平时就该做的,见第 5 条(病历和影像自己存一份)。封存是纠纷发生时把证据固定住,防的是事后补写和修改。怀疑是输液、输血、用药出的问题,除了病历,还要一起封存那袋液体、那支药和输液器,别让人收走扔掉。医疗机构应当在显著位置公布医疗纠纷的解决途径、程序和联系方式,并设置统一的投诉管理部门。有事先找那个部门,不要找当班医生理论。

YOUR PRIVATE LIST

Choose what to do with this idea

Related source entries

Original content by eternity4719 under CC BY 4.0. English translation is credited in the source notes. HowToLiveWorse adds a clearly labeled satirical response.

Full source and adaptation notes