03-023 · EVIDENCE A · SOURCE-SENSITIVE

When angry, don’t try to vent by smashing things, punching a bag, or going for a run — first calm your body down.

生气时别靠砸东西、打沙袋、跑一圈来发泄,先让身体慢下来

Source cost

No cost at all. When you’re angry, try a few minutes of activities that slow your heart rate: breathe slowly, sit down, and quiet your mind. It’s hard to resist the urge to vent right then and there.

Source return

Activities that rev up the body — like punching a bag, throwing things, or going for a run — generally don’t help you cool off. On the other hand, techniques that calm the body, such as slow breathing, mindfulness, and meditation, noticeably reduce anger and the urge to lash out.

Evidence grade

A

THE LOW-ROI DETOURSatire, not advice

Move “When angry, don’t try to vent by smashing things, punching a bag, or going for a run — first calm your body down.” to Future Me's calendar

The excuse

The routine already works until the day the source says it may not.

What feels good now

Today I keep a few minutes, a bit of persistence and avoid interrupting my default routine.

What the source says

The source summarizes the return this way: “Activities that rev up the body — like punching a bag, throwing things, or going for a run — generally don’t help you cool off. On the other hand, techniques that calm the body, such as slow breathing, mindfulness, and meditation, noticeably reduce anger and the urge to lash out.” Evidence grade A. The original states the population, caveats, and sources; this is not a personal forecast.

THE ENGLISH EDITION

Original recommendation and evidence

Source commit a994b6a0c905

23. When angry, don’t try to vent by smashing things, punching a bag, or going for a run — first calm your body down.

Cost: No cost at all. When you’re angry, try a few minutes of activities that slow your heart rate: breathe slowly, sit down, and quiet your mind. It’s hard to resist the urge to vent right then and there.

In plain terms: Activities that rev up the body — like punching a bag, throwing things, or going for a run — generally don’t help you cool off. On the other hand, techniques that calm the body, such as slow breathing, mindfulness, and meditation, noticeably reduce anger and the urge to lash out.

Benefit: A meta-analysis of 154 studies involving 184 sample groups and 10,189 participants shows that calming techniques like deep breathing, mindfulness, and meditation lower both anger and aggression. The effect size was g = -0.63, with a 95% CI ranging from -0.82 to -0.43. This result held true across genders, races, ages, and cultures. In contrast, activities that increase physical arousal — such as punching a bag, jogging, or cycling — showed virtually no effect; their effect size was g = -0.02, with a 95% CI from -0.13 to 0.09. The authors conclude that neither venting anger nor going for a run is an effective way to defuse it.

Evidence grade: A

Sources: Kjærvik SL, Bushman BJ (2024). A meta-analytic review of anger management activities that increase or decrease arousal: What fuels or douses rage? Clinical Psychology Review. <https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2024.102414>

Notes: These findings measure anger and aggression, not overall energy levels. The authors categorize the time spent on calming activities as “minutes saved from dealing with fallout after an argument.” Immediate techniques you can use right now include the “circular sighing” method described in Section 22, Item 9, and “stepping away when angry” in Rule 18 of this section (stepping away when angry). Running isn’t useless in the long run — it helps ease low mood, as noted in Section 22, Item 7 (“When feeling down, go for a walk or run”). It simply isn't a good short-term fix for anger. While angry, avoid driving, sending messages, or making important decisions. If someone is physically attacking you, leave the scene and call the police; your priority then is safety, not emotional regulation — see Section 8, Item 43 (“If you’re being abused”).

Read the complete Chinese source and notes

23. 生气时别靠砸东西、打沙袋、跑一圈来发泄,先让身体慢下来

成本: 不花钱。气头上改做几分钟让心跳慢下来的事:慢慢呼吸,坐下来,静一静。难在当时最想做的恰恰是发泄。

说人话: 打沙袋、摔东西、去跑一圈,这类让身体更兴奋的发泄办法,整体上消不了气。慢呼吸、正念、冥想这类让身体静下来的办法,能明显压下怒气和想动手的劲。

收益: 把 154 项研究合起来算(荟萃分析),共 184 组样本、10,189 人。让身体平静下来的办法,比如深呼吸、正念、冥想,能降低怒气和攻击性。效果大小 g = -0.63,95% CI -0.82 到 -0.43(可信范围)。这个结果在不同性别、种族、年龄和文化的人里都稳定。让身体更兴奋的办法,比如打沙袋、慢跑、骑车,整体无效。它的效果大小 g = -0.02,95% CI -0.13 到 0.09。作者的结论是:发泄怒气、去跑一圈,都不是管用的消气办法。

证据等级: A

来源: Kjærvik SL, Bushman BJ (2024). A meta-analytic review of anger management activities that increase or decrease arousal: What fuels or douses rage? Clinical Psychology Review. <https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2024.102414>

备注: 量的是怒气和攻击性,不是精力。口径记成时间,是作者的归类:少吵一架,就少收拾一次残局。当场能用的办法见第 22 节第 8 条(循环叹息),还有本节第 17 条(生气时先离场)。跑步不是没用。长期看,它对情绪低落有效,见第 22 节第 6 条(心情差就去走或者跑)。它只是不适合拿来当场消气。气头上别开车,别发消息,别做决定。如果是有人在打你,先离开、报警。那时要处理的不是你的情绪,见第 8 节第 43 条(被家暴了)。

Author's scope notes: 量的是怒气和攻击性,不是精力。口径记成时间,是作者的归类:少吵一架,就少收拾一次残局。当场能用的办法见第 22 节第 8 条(循环叹息),还有本节第 17 条(生气时先离场)。跑步不是没用。长期看,它对情绪低落有效,见第 22 节第 6 条(心情差就去走或者跑)。它只是不适合拿来当场消气。气头上别开车,别发消息,别做决定。如果是有人在打你,先离开、报警。那时要处理的不是你的情绪,见第 8 节第 43 条(被家暴了)。

YOUR PRIVATE LIST

Choose what to do with this idea

Related source entries

Original content by eternity4719 under CC BY 4.0. English translation is credited in the source notes. HowToLiveWorse adds a clearly labeled satirical response.

Full source and adaptation notes