08-004 · EVIDENCE B · SOURCE-SENSITIVE

Seeing a face on video or hearing a voice on the phone does not count as verification; if a transfer is involved, hang up first and call back using an old number saved in your contacts.

视频里看见脸、电话里听见声音都不算核实,涉及转账先挂断,用自己通讯录里的旧号码打回去

Source cost

No cost involved. It only requires making one extra call and waiting a few extra minutes. In general, avoid posting videos of your face or long voice recordings on public accounts. The hard part is that scammers often pressure you to act quickly — you must resist the urge to transfer money right away.

Source return

Seeing someone’s face or hearing their voice is not reliable proof of identity. Whenever money transfer is mentioned, hang up immediately and call back using an old number stored in your contacts, or ask someone you both know. If the caller claims “poor signal” or “I’m in a meeting” and refuses a live video chat, treat it as a scam.

Evidence grade

B

THE LOW-ROI DETOURSatire, not advice

Move “Seeing a face on video or hearing a voice on the phone does not count as verification; if a transfer is involved, hang up first and call back using an old number saved in your contacts.” to Future Me's calendar

The excuse

There is no immediate alarm, so the sensible choice can wait for a less busy week.

What feels good now

Today I keep a few minutes, a bit of persistence and avoid interrupting my default routine.

What the source says

The source summarizes the return this way: “Seeing someone’s face or hearing their voice is not reliable proof of identity. Whenever money transfer is mentioned, hang up immediately and call back using an old number stored in your contacts, or ask someone you both know. If the caller claims “poor signal” or “I’m in a meeting” and refuses a live video chat, treat it as a scam.” Evidence grade B. The original states the population, caveats, and sources; this is not a personal forecast.

THE ENGLISH EDITION

Original recommendation and evidence

Source commit a994b6a0c905

4. Seeing a face on video or hearing a voice on the phone does not count as verification; if a transfer is involved, hang up first and call back using an old number saved in your contacts.

Cost: No cost involved. It only requires making one extra call and waiting a few extra minutes. In general, avoid posting videos of your face or long voice recordings on public accounts. The hard part is that scammers often pressure you to act quickly — you must resist the urge to transfer money right away.

In plain terms: Seeing someone’s face or hearing their voice is not reliable proof of identity. Whenever money transfer is mentioned, hang up immediately and call back using an old number stored in your contacts, or ask someone you both know. If the caller claims “poor signal” or “I’m in a meeting” and refuses a live video chat, treat it as a scam.

Benefit: The Cybersecurity Bureau of the Ministry of Public Security has outlined three key measures. First is motion verification: ask the other party to perform a smooth head-turn motion, or to completely cover their face with a palm and then remove it quickly. The original text notes that current AI technology still struggles to accurately simulate such complex facial occlusions and lighting changes, often resulting in choppy, blurry, or distorted images. Second is listening for audio cues: AI-generated voices sometimes lack natural breathing pauses or emotional variation, and may sound slightly mechanical or contain unusual background noise. Third and most important is cross-channel verification. As stated in the source material, “after hanging up, immediately call a number the person regularly uses and you recognize — do not call back the suspicious number — or ask a mutual acquaintance for confirmation.” The rule of thumb is: “Don’t trust video or voice alone; verify through actions and multiple channels.” Legally, using face-swapping or voice-cloning technology for fraud is strictly prohibited. Platforms must clearly label any service offering face generation, replacement, voice synthesis, or voice imitation; no organization or individual may remove, alter, or hide such labels. However, since scammers rarely follow these rules, the absence of a label cannot be taken as proof that the caller is genuine. The Criminal Investigation Bureau reported one case where a 14-member gang produced over 50000 synthetic face videos and collected more than 500000 pieces of personal information; police also seized 60 cloud servers nationwide. This labeling requirement took effect on September 1, 2025.

Evidence grade: B

Sources: Ministry of Public Security of China Cybersecurity Bureau (2025). Seeing is believing, beware of new AI scams! <http://gat.fujian.gov.cn/ztzl/fjjffpzxrx/spjq/202509/t20250922_7013008.htm> (Reprinted by the Fujian Provincial Public Security Department); National Internet Information Office, Ministry of Industry and Information Technology of China, Ministry of Public Security of China (2022). Provisions on the In-depth Synthesis Management of Internet Information Services (Sixth, Sixteenth, Article 17, effective January 10, 2023). <https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2022-12/12/content_5731431.htm>; Cyberspace Administration of China, Ministry of Industry and Information Technology of China, Ministry of Public Security of China, State Administration of Radio and Television (2025). Methods for labeling synthetic content generated by artificial intelligence (Article 10, 2025-9 Effective on January 1st). <https://www.cac.gov.cn/2025-03/14/c_1743654684782215.htm>; Ministry of Public Security of China Criminal Investigation Bureau, CCTV News (2026). The police seized more than 50,000 synthetic dynamic face videos. Who is "copying" your face? <http://gat.fujian.gov.cn/ztzl/fjjffpzxrx/spjq/202603/t20260330_7117146.htm> (Reprinted by Fujian Provincial Public Security Department)

Notes: Always use an old number saved in your contacts when calling back — never dial the number shown on the incoming call or any new number the scammer provides. If the caller cites “poor signal” or “a meeting” to avoid a live video or motion test, assume it is a scam. Motion verification is only a supplementary tool; since AI capabilities keep improving, the only truly reliable step remains cross-channel confirmation. If money has already been transferred, refer to section 2 of this chapter and call 110 immediately to request a stop on the payment. For information on protecting your own facial and voice data, see section 14. This item is rated B because official sources provide identification methods and case examples, but no statistics are given on how much these measures actually reduce fraud rates. The main Ministry of Public Security website (mps.gov.cn) remains inaccessible due to a 521 error; the quoted texts from the Cybersecurity Bureau and Criminal Investigation Bureau were taken from a republishing page run by the Fujian Provincial Public Security Department.

Read the complete Chinese source and notes

4. 视频里看见脸、电话里听见声音都不算核实,涉及转账先挂断,用自己通讯录里的旧号码打回去

成本: 不花钱。多打一个电话,多等几分钟。平时少在公开账号上发正脸视频和大段语音。难在对方常常催得很急,你要忍住不当场转账。

说人话: 看见脸、听见声音,都不算核实。只要涉及转账就先挂断,再用自己通讯录里存的旧号码打回去,或者找共同认识的人问一句。对方说「信号不好」「在开会」,不肯当面视频,直接当骗局处理。

收益: 公安部网安局给了三条办法。第一条是动作验证:请对方做一个连贯的转头动作,或者用手掌完全遮住脸再快速移开。原文说「目前的 AI 技术在模拟这些复杂的面部遮挡和光影变化时,容易出现卡顿、模糊或扭曲」。第二条是听声音细节:「AI 生成的语音有时会缺乏自然的呼吸停顿、情感起伏,或者带有轻微的机械感、背景杂音异常」。第三条是多渠道核实。原文说这是「最核心的一招」:「挂断后直接拨打对方常用且你熟悉的电话号码(不要回拨可疑来电号码),或者通过你们共同认识的第三人进行侧面核实」。口诀是「视频语音莫轻信,动作验证多核实」。法律上,换脸换声早就被禁止用于诈骗。人脸生成、人脸替换、合成人声、仿声这几类服务,平台必须打上显著标识。任何组织和个人不得恶意删除、篡改、伪造、隐匿这个标识。但守规矩的是平台,骗子不会加,所以「没看到 AI 标识」不能反过来当成对方是真人的证据。公安部刑侦局公布过一起案件。14 人团伙被查获合成动态人脸视频 5 万多条,公民个人信息 50 多万条。警方还扣押了云服务器 60 台(全国,标识义务自 2025 年 9 月 1 日起)

证据等级: B

来源: 公安部网安局 (2025). 眼见≠为实,警惕 AI 新型诈骗!<http://gat.fujian.gov.cn/ztzl/fjjffpzxrx/spjq/202509/t20250922_7013008.htm>(福建省公安厅转载);国家互联网信息办公室、工业和信息化部、公安部 (2022). 互联网信息服务深度合成管理规定(第六、十六、十七条,2023 年 1 月 10 日施行). <https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2022-12/12/content_5731431.htm>;国家互联网信息办公室、工业和信息化部、公安部、国家广播电视总局 (2025). 人工智能生成合成内容标识办法(第十条,2025 年 9 月 1 日施行). <https://www.cac.gov.cn/2025-03/14/c_1743654684782215.htm>;公安部刑侦局、央视新闻 (2026). 警方查获 5 万多条合成动态人脸视频 谁在「复制」你的脸?<http://gat.fujian.gov.cn/ztzl/fjjffpzxrx/spjq/202603/t20260330_7117146.htm>(福建省公安厅转载)

备注: 回拨要用自己通讯录里存的旧号码。不要回拨来电显示的那个号码,也不要用对方在聊天里发来的新号码。对方以「信号不好」「在开会」为由不肯当面视频、不肯做指定动作的,直接当骗局处理。动作验证法只是辅助,AI 一直在变好,唯一稳的是第三条核实。已经转了钱,见本节第 2 条(立刻打 110 要求止付)。防止自己的人脸和声音被采集见第 14 节。定 B 级是因为官方给的是识别办法和案例,没有「按这个方法核实后被骗率下降多少」的数字。公安部官网(mps.gov.cn)这次仍然全站 521 打不开,公安部网安局和刑侦局的原文取自福建省公安厅的转载页。

Author's scope notes: 回拨要用自己通讯录里存的旧号码。不要回拨来电显示的那个号码,也不要用对方在聊天里发来的新号码。对方以「信号不好」「在开会」为由不肯当面视频、不肯做指定动作的,直接当骗局处理。动作验证法只是辅助,AI 一直在变好,唯一稳的是第三条核实。已经转了钱,见本节第 2 条(立刻打 110 要求止付)。防止自己的人脸和声音被采集见第 14 节。定 B 级是因为官方给的是识别办法和案例,没有「按这个方法核实后被骗率下降多少」的数字。公安部官网(mps.gov.cn)这次仍然全站 521 打不开,公安部网安局和刑侦局的原文取自福建省公安厅的转载页。

YOUR PRIVATE LIST

Choose what to do with this idea

Related source entries

Original content by eternity4719 under CC BY 4.0. English translation is credited in the source notes. HowToLiveWorse adds a clearly labeled satirical response.

Full source and adaptation notes