13-036 · EVIDENCE C · SOURCE-SENSITIVE

If a stranger demands money in a remote area, hand over cash, avoid any confrontation, note their features, and call police after escaping

荒郊野外被陌生人索财,钱给他,不动手,记特征,脱身后报警

Source cost

The cash you have on you. The real challenge is keeping your temper in check.

Source return

Give him the money, do not fight back, and do not argue. By demanding a few hundred yuan, he is committing robbery — a crime punishable by at least three years up to ten years in prison. If he enters a residence, uses a weapon, or causes serious injury or death, the sentence rises to ten years or more, even life imprisonment or death. If you chase after him and strike him after he has taken the money, that is no longer considered self‑defence. Immediately after escaping, write down his appearance, accent, vehicle license plate, and the direction he fled, then call 110.

Evidence grade

C

THE LOW-ROI DETOURSatire, not advice

Move “If a stranger demands money in a remote area, hand over cash, avoid any confrontation, note their features, and call police after escaping” to Future Me's calendar

The excuse

I can spend longer deciding whether to start than the small action would take.

What feels good now

Today I keep a little money, a few minutes, a bit of persistence and avoid interrupting my default routine.

What the source says

The source summarizes the return this way: “Give him the money, do not fight back, and do not argue. By demanding a few hundred yuan, he is committing robbery — a crime punishable by at least three years up to ten years in prison. If he enters a residence, uses a weapon, or causes serious injury or death, the sentence rises to ten years or more, even life imprisonment or death. If you chase after him and strike him after he has taken the money, that is no longer considered self‑defence. Immediately after escaping, write down his appearance, accent, vehicle license plate, and the direction he fled, then call 110.” Evidence grade C. The original states the population, caveats, and sources; this is not a personal forecast.

THE ENGLISH EDITION

Original recommendation and evidence

Source commit a994b6a0c905

36. If a stranger demands money in a remote area, hand over cash, avoid any confrontation, note their features, and call police after escaping

Cost: The cash you have on you. The real challenge is keeping your temper in check.

In plain terms: Give him the money, do not fight back, and do not argue. By demanding a few hundred yuan, he is committing robbery — a crime punishable by at least three years up to ten years in prison. If he enters a residence, uses a weapon, or causes serious injury or death, the sentence rises to ten years or more, even life imprisonment or death. If you chase after him and strike him after he has taken the money, that is no longer considered self‑defence. Immediately after escaping, write down his appearance, accent, vehicle license plate, and the direction he fled, then call 110.

Benefit: Your life is far more valuable than a few hundred yuan. The offender is committing a serious crime for such a small amount. Article 263 of the Criminal Law states that anyone who robs public or private property by violence, coercion, or other means faces three to ten years in prison plus a fine; aggravating circumstances raise the penalty to ten years or more, even death. Article 20 limits self‑defence to stopping an ongoing unlawful attack; once the robber has taken the money and walked away, any retaliation is no longer justified. After escaping, record his description, speech patterns, vehicle details, and escape route, then call 110.

Evidence grade: C

Sources: National People's Congress (amended in 2020). Criminal Law (Article 20, Article 263). <https://jtgl.beijing.gov.cn/jgj/jgxx/flfg/fl/11033925/index.html> (Reprinted and integrated text by Beijing Municipal Public Security and Traffic Management Bureau)

Notes: The “C” rating reflects the lack of direct literature supporting the principle that “handing over money avoids danger”; the legal text merely outlines the offender’s risks and your boundaries. Never follow an attacker to a secluded spot to “get money,” never reveal your phone password, and never get into his vehicle. This advice is not an invitation to fight or to refrain from calling police; it applies only when you are physically threatened in a remote setting and must first pay to ensure your safety. In contrast, if someone online threatens to release private photos or videos, you must never pay — see Section 8, Item 32 for those cases.

Read the complete Chinese source and notes

36. 荒郊野外被陌生人索财,钱给他,不动手,记特征,脱身后报警

成本: 身上的现金。难的是压住火气。

说人话: 钱给他,不动手,不还嘴。对方为几百块冒的是抢劫罪:三年以上十年以下起步,入户、持枪、致人重伤死亡的十年以上,直到死刑。他拿了钱转身走,你追上去打就不再算正当防卫。脱身后立刻记下体貌、口音、车牌和逃跑方向,打 110。

收益: 命比钱贵,对方为几百元冒的是重罪。刑法第二百六十三条规定,以暴力、胁迫或者其他方法抢劫公私财物的,处三年以上十年以下有期徒刑并处罚金。持枪、入户、致人重伤死亡等情形,判十年以上直至死刑。刑法第二十条的正当防卫只保护「制止正在进行的不法侵害」。对方拿了钱转身走,你追上去打就不再是防卫。脱身后立刻记下体貌、口音、车牌、逃跑方向,打 110

证据等级: C

来源: 全国人大 (2020 年修正). 刑法(第二十条、第二百六十三条). <https://jtgl.beijing.gov.cn/jgj/jgxx/flfg/fl/11033925/index.html>(北京市公安交管局转载整合文本)

备注: C 级原因是「给钱不对抗更安全」没有直接文献,法条只说明对方的风险和你的边界。不要跟去偏僻处「取钱」。不要交手机密码。不要上对方的车。先给钱只限当面被堵住、人身安全受威胁的场合,脱身后照样报警。网上被人拿隐私照片、裸聊录像来要钱是反过来的,一分钱都不能给,见第 8 节第 32 条(对方拿把柄来要钱)。别指望随身带的甩棍、电击器、匕首,带着出门本身就会被罚,见第 9 节第 26 条(别为了防身买甩棍、电击器)。

Author's scope notes: C 级原因是「给钱不对抗更安全」没有直接文献,法条只说明对方的风险和你的边界。不要跟去偏僻处「取钱」。不要交手机密码。不要上对方的车。先给钱只限当面被堵住、人身安全受威胁的场合,脱身后照样报警。网上被人拿隐私照片、裸聊录像来要钱是反过来的,一分钱都不能给,见第 8 节第 32 条(对方拿把柄来要钱)。别指望随身带的甩棍、电击器、匕首,带着出门本身就会被罚,见第 9 节第 26 条(别为了防身买甩棍、电击器)。

YOUR PRIVATE LIST

Choose what to do with this idea

Related source entries

Original content by eternity4719 under CC BY 4.0. English translation is credited in the source notes. HowToLiveWorse adds a clearly labeled satirical response.

Full source and adaptation notes